home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=93TT0396>
- <title>
- Dec. 02, 1993: The Shadow Of The Law
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1993
- Dec. 02, 1993 Special Issue:The New Face Of America
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- SPECIAL ISSUE:THE NEW FACE OF AMERICA
- The Shadow Of The Law, Page 16
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>For illegal aliens, life in a new land is mostly one of poverty,
- anxiety and loneliness
- </p>
- <p>By Michael Walsh--Reported by Massimo Calabresi and Sribala Subramanian/New
- York and Jeanne McDowell/Los Angeles
- </p>
- <p> No one knows exactly how many illegal immigrants are in the
- U.S. The Immigration and Naturalization Service estimate is
- 3.2 million, with an additional 200,000 to 300,000 arriving
- each year. Most come from the Third World--the list is topped
- by Mexico, followed by sizable minorities from El Salvador,
- Guatemala and Haiti--but Canada and Poland also contribute
- a good share. The illegals cross the porous border from Baja
- California, heading north to Los Angeles, where the wages are
- relatively high and the questions relatively few. They come
- from China, in coffin ships like the Golden Venture, in quest
- of asylum. They fly in from Ireland, willing to pull a few pints
- or pound a few nails in exchange for some greenbacks and, if
- they're lucky, a green card.
- </p>
- <p> What they often find, though, is hardship, privation, loneliness
- and exploitation. Although afforded some protection under American
- labor and civil rights laws, most illegals live in a shadow
- world of piecework and day jobs, just one step ahead of the
- INS and an unwanted ticket home. Whatever their country of origin,
- however, each illegal comes seeking the same thing: the good
- life in the good land.
- </p>
- <p> "Do you know where I can get work?" The question echoes from
- the walls of the St. Francis Center in downtown Los Angeles,
- where dozens of hungry men, most of them Hispanic and many of
- them illegals, gather at 7:30 a.m. for a hot meal of rice-and-bean
- soup before seeking a day's employment. For the past six months,
- ever since he arrived in L.A., Luis M., 36, has taken his morning
- nourishment at the soup kitchen and then wandered over to a
- street corner in the garment district, where a strong back can
- earn around $20 a day. "A guy will come in a truck and say he
- needs one or two workers, and everyone rushes to him," he explains.
- </p>
- <p> The work is hard: unloading 200-lb. bolts of wrapped garments,
- hauling them upstairs and unpacking them. A documented worker
- might earn $13 an hour for such labor; Luis gets $5. "Even if
- we paid our legals three times as much, they still would not
- do this work," observes the job's foreman.
- </p>
- <p> Some of what Luis earns he sends back to Vera Cruz, Mexico,
- where his wife (her name is America) lives with their three
- sons. It's been five years since the itinerant Luis first slipped
- across the border. "I haven't been able to accomplish what I
- wanted to do here," he says wanly. "I wanted to get a steady
- job as a driver and bring my family here."
- </p>
- <p> Like many other illegals, Luis is caught in the familiar catch-22:
- employers are loath to hire him because he lacks a driver's
- license, and he cannot get a driver's license because he has
- no Social Security card. So he watches his dream die a little
- each day. "I feel like I'm not worth anything," he says. "But
- I have to stick it out."
- </p>
- <p> How are men like Luis able to avoid the immigration laws with
- such impunity? The answer is that the INS is simply outmanned:
- with 6,000 miles of open borders, a burgeoning population of
- illegals and a relatively static force of only 5,600 agents,
- the U.S. has effectively lost control of its territorial integrity,
- especially in the Southwest. Duke Austin, a senior INS spokesman
- in Washington, puts it bluntly: "The system is--there's no
- other word--bankrupt, in money and resources."
- </p>
- <p> Many, if not most Americans, in fact, incline to a live-and-let-live
- policy in recognition of the illegals' economic contributions.
- Vigorous lobbying by both the American Civil Liberties Union
- and their legal countrymen has sought to protect the status
- of illegals. The A.C.L.U. has consistently opposed any form
- of national employment-authorization identity card, and the
- illegals' countrymen have helped pass ordinances in states such
- as California and New York making it unlawful for authorities
- to inquire about a person's visa status; until Governor Wilson's
- recent revocation of such ordinances by local communities in
- his state, San Francisco and other municipalities had declared
- themselves as sanctuaries for undocumented workers.
- </p>
- <p> Even in places where it is easy to hide, some illegals are actively
- pursuing legitimacy. Quiet and self-effacing, H. Lin, 30, a
- young factory worker from the rural province of Fujian in China,
- left his family behind in the old country earlier this year
- to seek his fortune in America. For a fee of $30,000, which
- he borrowed, he was smuggled into the country by plane at Honolulu.
- Confronted by the INS, Lin claimed political asylum, boarded
- another plane and promptly disappeared into the nearly impenetrable
- subculture of New York City's Chinatown.
- </p>
- <p> Lin's experience in America has been typical. Assured by the
- smugglers (the Chinese call them "snakeheads") that he would
- be warmly received, Lin was first hired as a day laborer at
- a Chinese restaurant, where he worked 14-hour shifts for less
- than $2 an hour, shucking shrimp and cleaning latrines. Then
- he was fired after two weeks to make room for another illegal
- who could pony up the $60 employment-agency fee that new arrivals
- are routinely charged. Now Lin is busy sewing labels and zippers
- on counterfeit designer jeans in a Brooklyn sweatshop, earning
- about $800 a month in exchange for a 12-hour day, six days a
- week.
- </p>
- <p> Some of that money will go back to China, to pay off Lin's debt.
- But, roughly $1,300 will go to Lin's lawyer, who is helping
- him with his asylum application. Like many other Chinese, Lin
- tells a story of his wife's forced, botched abortions and his
- threatened sterilization back home, the ugly realities of China's
- one-family, one-child policy. Chances are he will be approved,
- as are 55% of Chinese applicants.
- </p>
- <p> And if he is not? He will probably stay anyway. "If they're
- denied or don't show for their hearing, do we go look for them?"
- asks INS spokesman Austin. "No."
- </p>
- <p> Because most Americans are themselves descendants of immigrants,
- there has traditionally been a laissez-faire attitude toward
- all forms of immigration. While there is a growing backlash
- against stereotypical nonwhite illegals--the Mexican wetback,
- the smuggled Chinese--one group for which undocumented status
- is generally just a temporary inconvenience is the Irish. Thanks
- to the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1990, which included
- a liberal green-card lottery pushed through by Irish-American
- politicians, thousands of Irish have been legalized. Most of
- the estimated 37,000 illegal Irish in the U.S. who have not
- yet won a green card are patiently waiting their turn, the majority
- in relative comfort.
- </p>
- <p> Colm M., 25, is a Belfast-born barman and bouncer. More a charmer
- than a strongarm, Colm arrived in New York as a teenager. His
- father came originally to escape "the troubles." Colm, his mother
- and three siblings followed on visitor's visas and stayed on.
- "There was nothing there for us," he explains. Even so, it took
- him years to adjust to American cultural attitudes. "In Ireland
- everybody was afraid of the teacher, but here the kid would
- tell the teacher to F off. In Ireland you could get killed for
- that. First the teacher would kill you; then your dad would
- kill you."
- </p>
- <p> Like many illegal Irish, Colm began by working in the building
- trades as a "J.F.K. carpenter," as the new Irish arrivals at
- New York City's John F. Kennedy International Airport were called.
- "As soon as you get off the plane they hand you a toolbox and
- you go to work." He has also moonlighted as a fiacre driver
- in Central Park and a boxer in Atlantic City, New Jersey, although
- his real ambition is someday to be a cop or fireman.
- </p>
- <p> In the tightly knit Irish community, where word of mouth substitutes
- for Help Wanted ads, there is always plenty of work, and Colm's
- income has hovered around $30,000 a year. Yet he lacks the important
- little things that validate life in America. Though he has a
- legal driver's license, his Social Security number is invented
- and his apartment is rented in the name of an ex-girlfriend.
- "The thing of it is, I've been here since I was 15 years old,
- I've worked hard, and I've never committed a crime," he says.
- "This is my home, but yet it's not. That's the hard part."
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-